Preferred stocks vs. common stocks vs. bonds

Discover the key differences between Preferred Stocks vs. Common Stocks vs. Bonds, including cash flow claims, asset priority, and tax impact, to optimize your investment strategy.

Manish Hemrajani6 min readPublished Updated

Five points determine where common stock, preferred stock, and bonds fit in a portfolio:

  • Cash flow claim

  • Asset priority

  • Upside

  • Maturity

  • Tax treatment

The old “hybrid” label does not explain any of them.

Why the “hybrid” label falls short

New investors in preferred stock often call it a mix of stock and bond. That is not false, but it hides more than it shows.

The better test is to compare all three instruments—common stock, preferred stock, and senior bonds—across the traits that drive risk and return. That is the simplest way to see the difference between preferred and common stock.

Claim on cash flow

Start with cash flow.

Common stock

Common shareholders get dividends only after all other claims are paid. The board decides whether to pay anything at all, and there is no set rate. A company can skip dividends for years and owe common holders no reason beyond its stock price.

Preferred stock

Preferred shareholders get a fixed dividend rate, but payment is often optional in most structures. A company can stop it without default, though many terms block common dividends while preferred dividends stay unpaid.

Bonds

Bondholders get a fixed coupon that the contract requires. Missing a payment is default and usually speeds up the debt, giving creditors legal leverage.

Claim on assets

Now look at assets.

In liquidation, repayment usually follows this order:

  1. Secured creditors

  2. Senior unsecured bondholders

  3. Junior debt holders

  4. Preferred shareholders

  5. Common shareholders

This order, often called the capital stack, is the most important idea in income investing. It shows who takes the first losses when a company runs into trouble.

The 2008-09 crisis made this plain. At failed firms, senior bondholders often got back a fair share of their claims, while preferred and common holders often got little or nothing.

Upside participation

Upside is just as different.

Common stock

Common stock offers no cap on gains. If the company does well, common holders can see their capital grow many times over.

Preferred stock and bonds

Preferred stock and bonds are capped. Their prices do not usually climb far above par, or above the value of their remaining cash flows.

The reason is straightforward: the cash flow remains constant regardless of business performance, and the issuer frequently has the option to redeem the security at a predetermined price.

A holder of a strong company’s preferred shares gets the same stated dividend as a holder of a modest company’s preferred shares.

Same issuer, different securities

A good way to make this concrete is to look at one large bank that has all three instruments outstanding.

Senior notes

Its senior notes may yield the least of the three because they have the strongest claim.

Preferred shares

Preferred shares might give a return that is one to two percentage points higher. This happens because they are lower in rank, have some flexibility in paying dividends, and don’t have a set maturity date.

Common shares

Its common shares may have a dividend yield that is below the bond yield or above the preferred yield. But that payout can be cut, and the share price can swing with earnings, mood, and the economy.

Same issuer. Same business. Three very different securities.

Maturity and duration

Maturity and duration finish the picture.

Bonds

Bonds mature on a set date, when principal is repaid. That helps anchor value.

Preferred stock

Most preferred stock is perpetual, with no maturity date. Most issues do, however, give the issuer—not the investor—the right to redeem after a set date.

No maturity anchor makes fixed-rate preferreds very sensitive to long-term rates.

The asset class demonstrated that in 2022, when rates increased quickly, many investment-grade preferreds dropped by 20% or more, even though credit quality remained stable.

Taxation

Taxation cuts across the three groups.

Bonds

The tax authorities treat bond interest as ordinary income.

Preferred stock

Most traditional preferred dividends qualify for the lower tax rates used for qualified dividend income.

Common stock

Common dividends usually qualify for those lower rates as well.

For investors in higher tax brackets with taxable accounts, this can change the after-tax ranking of similar yields.

Portfolio role

Taken together, these differences explain why preferred stock and baby bonds sit in the middle of most income portfolios:

  • Higher yield than investment-grade bonds

  • Lower swings than common stock in most markets

  • A risk profile that looks like neither one exactly

The investor’s job is not to pick one best category. It is to know what each one pays for, and to size positions with care.

Disclosures

Library articles give general information about securities and markets. They are not advice on any security, or on whether to buy or sell it.

Q&A

Question: Why is calling preferred stock a “hybrid” not enough?

Short answer: The label is too broad to show the common stock vs preferred stock differences that matter.

Preferred stock possesses some characteristics similar to bonds, like a fixed dividend rate. However, there are significant differences: the dividends are generally optional, preferred shareholders are below creditors in the event of liquidation, most preferred stocks lack a maturity date, and the potential for gain is limited.

Looking at cash flow claims, asset priority, upside, maturity, and tax treatment gives a clearer view.

Question: Why do preferred shares usually yield more than senior bonds from the same issuer?

Short answer: Preferred shares usually sit lower in the capital stack than senior bonds, so they take losses sooner if the company gets into trouble. Their dividends can often be suspended without causing default, and many preferreds are perpetual rather than tied to a set maturity date. Investors usually want a higher yield to make up for those added risks.

Question: If preferred stock pays a fixed dividend, why can its price still fall sharply?

Short answer: A fixed dividend does not protect the market price. Most preferred stock has no maturity date, so there is no set point when principal must come back to the investor. That makes fixed-rate preferreds sensitive to long-term rates. When rates rise, older fixed-rate preferreds can be less attractive, and their prices can fall even if the issuer’s credit quality has not worsened.

Question: How does upside differ among common stock, preferred stock, and bonds?

Short answer: Common stock has the most upside because its value can rise with earnings, growth, and investor mood. Preferred stock and bonds are capped. Their cash flows are fixed, and prices usually do not rise far above par or redemption value. A preferred shareholder of a strong company usually gets the same stated dividend as a preferred shareholder of a merely average company.

Question: Why does taxation matter when comparing yields?

Short answer: The stated yield is not always the after-tax yield. Bond interest is taxed as ordinary income, while most traditional preferred dividends and common dividends qualify for lower qualified dividend tax rates. For investors in higher tax brackets using taxable accounts, that difference can change which security gives the better after-tax return.

Library articles are general information about securities and markets. They are not advice on any security or on whether to buy or sell it. Disclosures

The preferred stocks list shows every public record with its price, coupon, call date and yield.

The preferred stocks list
The newsletter

One issue, every Sunday.

Eight blocks of data, one chart, no commentary. Rates, the week's movers, listings and filings across preferred stocks, BDCs and covered-call ETFs.

Free · Sundays · unsubscribe at any time · addresses are never shared